This is my checklist in which I have
collected all my knowledge.
I think using this list could improve
your attention to the span of tools in your hands.
Please be aware, that the list builds
upon your knowledge and experience, which means you can work through this checklist and think
you really heeded everything while you didn't.
Of course a good illustration doesn't
have to meet all these points. It would be absolute overkill to use
all the list in a single illustration.
Certainly it depends on your style and
the illustration's purpose.
This is merely a list of the visual
tools available.
Composition
Eye
The eye stays inside the composition
All the format is used (does not necessarily mean being filled)
Shapes
Shapes fit the nature of the illustrated
Elements overlap and create depth
The negative space is interesting
aswell
Focus
The compositional elements create a focus point(s) or keep the eye inside the
illustration (using implied lines)
Some contrast is used to create a focus (read more under Elaboration/Contrast)
Construction
Anatomy
The anatomy of the characters is
correct (if you aim for fantastic realism)
The anatomy of creatures makes sense
to a certain extent (depends of course)
Design
Patterns, colors or shapes repeat in
some way
The designs look cool and/or believable but seems to
function as well *
Narration
Actions are understandable
A Story is told *
Perspective
The angle is interesting, emphasizing the Illustrated as much as necessary
The buildings etc are constructed correctly.
Foreshortening creates even more depth
(It does not have to be realistic. It just has to look right and remember:
everything must serve the
illustration.)
Light
The mood fits the illustrated
The light bounces off materials
correctly
The shadows are placed well (everything must serve the illustration)
Elaboration
Contrast
Contrast in saturation
Contrast in mass
Contrast in detail
Contrast in value
Contrast in quality
Materials
Each material is clearly looking like
what it is
The illustration contains a variety of materials
Quality
The quality fits the purpose / does not impede the purpose
Shapes are clean except if they
shouldn't on purpose
It is the best you can do
Accuracy
The characters are recognizable
Everything is accurate to the Style Guide
/ Reference / Concepts*
*(Of course only if it is necessary or asked for)
If you have any suggestions please let me know
aerozopher@gmail.com
hail to the circle
